(1) Montreux Capital Management (UK) Ltd (2) MCM UK (Group) Holdings Ltd (3) Montreux Group (Holdings) Ltd v (1) John Godden (2) Wentworth Hall Consultancy Ltd (3) Ian Morley (2018)

Judgment Date: 21 Mar 18

Summary The court did not grant summary judgment in a dispute over the terms of a settlement agreement where it was at least arguable that a deal carried out by the defendant did not qualify as such under the agreement and where the objective meaning of the words in the...

(1) Richard Toone (2) Kevin Murphy v (1) Dean Robbins (2) Richard Robbins (2018)

Judgment Date: 20 Mar 18

Summary Two company directors were required to repay to joint liquidators payments which they had received from the company which they had failed to demonstrate had been lawfully paid by way of remuneration. Facts Two joint liquidators appealed against a decision that the payment of £10,098 to the defendant company directors...

Michael Tuke v JD Classics Ltd (Formerly JD Classics Holdings Ltd) (2018)

Judgment Date: 16 Mar 18

Summary Where a claimant had served a notice to prove after the original deadline for service of witness statements, the notice was out of time, pursuant to CPR r.32.19(2)(a). The fact that a judge struck out the bulk of the witness statements which had been served and set a...

(1) Sally Woodward (2) Mark Addison v Phoenix Healthcare Distribution Ltd (2018)

Judgment Date: 16 Mar 18

Summary A party's entitlement to take advantage of its opponent's mistakes was qualified by its duty under CPR r.1.3 to help the court further the overriding objective. Where a party threatened with litigation failed to draw the proposed claimant's attention to a mistake which resulted in service being defective, that...

Frederick & Ors v Positive Solutions (Financial Services) Ltd (2018)

Judgment Date: 13 Mar 18

Summary A company providing financial advice was not vicariously liable for a fraud perpetrated by one of its agents. Although the fraud had involved an online portal the agent had had access to in his role as the company's agent, his wrongdoing had been part of a recognisably independent business...

Oyston v (1) Asker (2) SHCE Limited (2018)

Judgment Date: 13 Mar 18

Summary An interim injunction preventing a High Court enforcement officer from entering two residential premises to take goods to satisfy a large judgment debt was continued where there was a serious issue to be tried as to the proper construction of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 Sch.12 and whether...

Warborough Investments Ltd v Lunar Office SARL (2018)

Judgment Date: 13 Mar 18

Summary The grant of an underlease of commercial premises by a tenant had constituted a breach of covenant. A judge's construction of the relevant covenant had involved an unwarranted re-writing of it. Facts A landlord appealed against a decision that the grant of an underlease of commercial premises by the...

(1) Michael Rittson-Thomas (2) Hugo Rittson-Thomas (3) Rupert Rittson-Thomas (4) Kim Hughes v Oxfordshire County Council (2018)

Judgment Date: 09 Mar 18

Summary The Schools Sites Act 1841 s.2 allowed land to be granted as a site for a school and to revert to the grantor when that use ceased, unless s.14 applied and the land was sold or exchanged for a more eligible site. Section 14 did not mean that in order to...

Generator Developments Ltd v Lidl UK GmbH (2018)

Judgment Date: 08 Mar 18

Summary The Court of Appeal summarised the law applicable to equitable claims based on Pallant v Morgan [1953] Ch. 43. A property development company, which had been negotiating a joint venture with a supermarket for the purchase of land, did not have an interest in the land under Pallant v Morgan principles...