Clear Channel UK Ltd v Manchester City Council (2005)

Judgment Date: 09 Nov 05

Summary An agreement for the erection and maintenance of advertising displays on local authority land created a licence and not a tenancy, because the agreement between the parties did not sufficiently identify the land in respect of which a tenancy was said to have been created. Facts The appellant (C)...

Watergate Properties (Ellesmere) Limited v Securicor Cash Service Limited (2005)

Judgment Date: 08 Nov 05

Summary An arbitrator's decision, that on the true construction of a lease supplementary rent was required to be deducted from his determination of the yearly rental value, was obviously wrong. Facts The appellant landlord (W) appealed against an arbitrator's determination that supplementary rent was to be deducted from the yearly...

TSP Group Ltd v Globemark (UK) Ltd & Undersheriff of Cheshire (2005)

Judgment Date: 02 Nov 05

Summary A judge had been wrong to proceed to summarily determine a claim at a hearing that had been ordered to be a directions hearing. Facts The appellant company (T) appealed against a decision to summarily dismiss its claim to certain goods against the first respondent (G). T was the...

Simon Richard Fraser & Nathan George Fraser v Canterbury Diocesan Board Of Finance & Ors (2005

Judgment Date: 31 Oct 05

Summary There had been no reverter of the site of a school before the coming into force of the Reverter of Sites Act 1987, because until it had closed in 1995 the school had been used for the purpose of the education of poor persons within the School Sites Act 1841 s.2. Facts...

Velmore Estates Ltd & Ors v Roseberry Homes Ltd (2005)

Judgment Date: 31 Oct 05

Summary Where the appellant had a remedy in damages, he could not be required to mitigate his loss by accepting an offer that would deprive him of his remedy. Facts The appellant vendor (V) appealed against the refusal of an award of damages against the respondent purchaser (R). R had...

Munib Masri v Consolidated Contractors International (UK) Ltd & Ors (2005)

Judgment Date: 24 Oct 05

Summary The underlying purpose of Council Regulation 44/2001 Art.6 was to avoid the risk of irreconcilable judgments in separate proceedings. Where a defendant in one set of proceedings was domiciled in England and other defendants in separate English proceedings were domiciled outside England, Art.6.1 applied as the claims in both proceedings...

Shirayama Shokusan Co Ltd & Ors v Danovo Ltd (2005)

Judgment Date: 21 Oct 05

Summary The claimants were entitled to forfeit a sub-underlease granted to the defendant company, which traded as the Saatchi Gallery. Given the conduct of certain individuals behind the defendant, it was not appropriate to grant relief from forfeiture. Facts The claimant freeholder (S) brought a claim against the defendant sub-underlessee ...

Barlow Clowes International Ltd (In Liquidation) & Ors v Eurotrust International Ltd & Ors (2005)

Judgment Date: 10 Oct 05

Summary A person could know, and could certainly suspect, that he was assisting in a misappropriation of money without knowing that the money was held on trust or what a trust meant. Facts The appellant company (C), in liquidation, appealed against a decision that the second respondent (H) was not...

Burford (Fareham) Ltd v Christian Vision (2005)

Judgment Date: 07 Oct 05

Summary The Court ordered rectification of an assignment. Facts The claimant and the defendant entered into an agreement which provided (inter alia) that warranties held by the claimant would be assigned to the defendant. The assignment of certain such warranties (the A Warranties) was to be unconditional and to take...