SMQ v (1) RFQ (2) MJQ : RFQ v (1) MJQ (2) FBQ (2008)

Judgment Date: 31 Jul 08

Summary A proprietary estoppel arose in favour of a son who had paid for renovations on a property and moved into it in reliance on an agreement that the property would become his, contrary to his father's argument that he had retained ownership under an earlier agreement and that the...

Platform Funding Ltd v Bank of Scotland PLC (formerly Halifax PLC) (2008)

Judgment Date: 31 Jul 08

Summary The appellant firm of surveyors and valuers (X) appealed against a decision giving judgment for the respondent mortgage lender (P) on its claim for breach of contract. P had been approached by a borrower for a loan to be secured by a mortgage on a property. X purportedly provided...

Jirehouse Capital v Stanley Sherwin Beller (2008)

Judgment Date: 30 Jul 08

Summary The power of the court to make orders for security for costs against "companies" under CPR r.25.13(2)(c) was without distinction and included unlimited companies and those having only an individual member. Facts The appellant companies (J and K) appealed against a decision of the judge ordering them to...

Hameed v Qayyum (2008)

Judgment Date: 25 Jul 08

Summary An oral agreement to divide the interest in a property was valid despite the Law of Property Act 1925 s.53 : the agreement had been acted on, giving rise to a constructive trust, which took it outside the section by virtue of s.53(2). Facts The applicant creditor (C) applied for an...

Craig Guy McKinlay v Nexia Smith & Williamson Audit Ltd (2008)

Judgment Date: 18 Jul 08

Summary An ex-company director was entitled to damages from a firm of auditors in circumstances where the auditors were shown to have negligently undervalued his shareholding in a company. Facts The claimant (M) claimed damages against the defendant firm of auditors (N) for losses occasioned by its negligent valuation of...

Domain Dynamics (Holdings) Ltd v Revenue & Customs Commissioners (SpC00701) (2008)

Judgment Date: 17 Jul 08

Summary For the purposes of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 Sch.5B para.1(2)(f), "all the shares comprised in the issue" meant all shares of the same class issued by the company on the same day, and not all of the shares issued on that day for which the...

Sunberry Properties Ltd v Innovate Logistics Ltd (In Administration) & 5 Ors (2008)

Judgment Date: 15 Jul 08

Summary It was appropriate to grant the landlord of a company in administration leave to commence proceedings for an order terminating an occupational licence of premises when the licence had been granted in breach of an alienation covenant contained in the lease for the premises. Facts The applicant property company ...

(1) PA Snell (2) M Snell v Revenue & Customs Commissioners (SpC 699) (2008)

Judgment Date: 08 Jul 08

Summary Whilst a share sale had been entered into for bona fide commercial reasons, it also had as a main object the procuring of a tax advantage with the result that an assessment to income tax under the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988 s.793 had been properly made. Facts The...

Andrew Robert Olins v Harold Walters (2008)

Judgment Date: 04 Jul 08

Summary Where there was ample evidence that codicils executed by the defendant and his deceased wife satisfied the conditions for the establishment of mutual wills, the judge had been entitled to declare that they bound the deceased's estate in the hands of the defendant and his personal representatives. Facts The...